Renna's Pizza
Jacksonville, FL
New York Style Pizza at its Best! Celebrating 50 Years — Since 1976!
Order OnlineNOW OPEN — Deerwood Village
Baymeadows & Southside
9942 Old Baymeadows Rd, Jacksonville FL 32256
(904) 431-4444
↓ Scroll to explore
50 Years of Authentic New York Style Pizza in Jacksonville
In 1976, two brothers from Bari, Italy brought their family's culinary traditions to Jacksonville, Florida — and Renna's Pizza was born. What started as a single location has grown into five beloved restaurants across Jacksonville, each serving the same authentic New York-style pizza made with fresh ingredients, hand-tossed dough, and homemade sauces.
From our signature Renna's Deluxe and Joe's Special pizzas to handmade garlic knots, calzones, pasta dinners, and Italian subs — every dish is crafted with care and tradition that has made us a Jacksonville institution for half a century.
Read Our Story →Our Menu Favorites
Hand-crafted with fresh ingredients, made to order every time
Cheese / Build Your Own
Hand-tossed NY-style crust with homemade sauce and fresh mozzarella — customize with your favorite toppings
Renna's Deluxe
Pepperoni, onions, mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, sausage, ground beef, extra cheese
Garlic Knots
Homemade dough baked with olive oil and garlic, served with marinara sauce
Meatball Parmigiana
Homemade meatballs with marinara sauce, topped with melted mozzarella on toasted homemade bread
Homemade Lasagna
Sautéed ground beef, three cheeses, and spices layered in pasta with homemade sauce
Italian Cannoli
Made to order with sweet ricotta and chocolate chip filling, sprinkled with powdered sugar
Our Locations
5 locations across Jacksonville — find the one nearest you
Argyle Forest
Mandarin
Neptune Beach
Jax Beach
Deerwood Village
NEWFrequently Asked Questions
Does Renna's Pizza offer delivery?+
Yes! Our Argyle Forest and Mandarin locations offer delivery directly through our online ordering at rennaspizza.com. Our Neptune Beach, Jacksonville Beach, and Deerwood Village locations are available for delivery through DoorDash and Uber Eats.
Does Renna's Pizza offer catering?+
Yes, we cater events of all sizes across the Jacksonville area. Contact your nearest Renna's Pizza location by phone for catering inquiries and pricing.
Do you have a gluten-free pizza crust?+
We do not currently offer a gluten-free crust. Many of our salads and appetizers are naturally gluten-free — ask your location for details.
How many Renna's Pizza locations are there?+
We have 5 locations across Jacksonville: Argyle Forest, Mandarin, Neptune Beach, Jacksonville Beach, and Deerwood Village — our newest location.
How long has Renna's Pizza been open?+
Renna's Pizza has been serving Jacksonville since 1976 — over 50 years of authentic New York-style pizza made from family recipes.
Do you take reservations?+
We are a casual walk-in restaurant and do not take reservations. Online ordering is available for pickup and delivery at participating locations.
Ready to Order?
Fresh, authentic New York-style pizza — ready when you are.
Order Online